He has been injured the past couple seasons, but I'd never call him inconsistent. His greatest fault is the inability to get any run support from his team and a tendency to give up homers (not an outrageous number, but enough to lose when your team isn't scoring runs). And this year, he's been the best starter the Yankees have. I posted his stats the other day, but I'll do it again here, just to bug ya. ;)

His record is 4-1 and his ERA is a gorgeous (and difficult, in the AL East) 2.31.